Case note · Labour Appeal Court

CCMA v Mafete: a review is not an appeal

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Others v Mafete and Others [2026] ZALAC 50

11 November 2026

Labour Appeal Court, Johannesburg

Van Niekerk JA, Gqamana AJA and Moshoana AJA

Read the full judgment
All insights

The Labour Appeal Court has restored a commissioner’s finding that a SARS operations manager was fairly dismissed for assaulting a traveller at the Ramatlabama border post. The Labour Court had overturned that finding and reinstated him.

What happened

In 2018 the manager intervened in a dispute over customs fees, took a traveller’s bag and, according to her evidence and video footage, struck her in the throat. At his disciplinary hearing and at arbitration he denied the assault outright. The commissioner rejected his version and found the dismissal fair.

On review, the employee changed his case. He accepted that the contact may legally amount to assault, and argued for the first time that section 4(10) of the Customs and Excise Act allowed him to use force. The Labour Court accepted this, found the dismissal unfair and reinstated him.

What the court decided

The Labour Appeal Court upheld the appeal for two reasons. First, the Labour Court had treated the review as an appeal: it asked whether it agreed with the commissioner, instead of whether the award was one a reasonable decision-maker could reach on the evidence. Second, an employee cannot bring a new defence on review that was never put to the commissioner. His case at arbitration was a bare denial, and the statutory justification appeared only in his review papers.

What it means for employers

An arbitration award that is reasonably supported by the evidence will stand, even if a judge would have decided differently. Employers defending an award can resist new defences raised for the first time on review. For employees, the lesson is that every defence must be put at the disciplinary hearing and at arbitration.

Need advice on a dismissal?

Our attorneys advise employers and employees on disciplinary processes and dismissals every day.

WhatsApp us